Benefits and Drawbacks of each
Experiments: A test to see if something is true.
- A benefit for an experiment is that it is factual as you know you are getting real results because they have tried it out. You would need to use a controlled group to get compared answers (e.g. if your testing on a group of women, test men as well to compare)
- A drawback for this is that you have to get lots of results back e.g. experimenting on loads of pople to get a clear answer overall. Also a lot of people may not want to participate and you would have to persuade them.
Participant Observation: the researcher participates in the activity in order to better understand it.
-A benefit of this is you are able to get a clearer understanding of what your researching because your experiencing rather then just reading or hearing about it.
-A drawback of this is that you could be influenced by it after e.g. if you had to observe ganags you could be persuaded to join them after. Another thing is that you may get too involved in what your observing and may be distracted away from what your reseaching. You may also have a biased opinion on what your researching and your not thinking from both sides.
Historical Research: looking at the history and development of something, or studying old examples of something and comparing with contempary examples.
-A benefit of this is that the background information you find could help add a richer context to your research piece because you can see how times have changed over the years.
-A drawback of this is that your research may be out of date and have no help to you if your researching a modern piece (e.g. if you were researching technology there is noting to compare it to). Rhetorical Analysis: analysis of the techniques used to persuade the audience (can tell us something about the audience and the purpose of the text).
-A drawback of this is that it shows you what the makers of that product think of the audience and that doesnt help us because the audience will respond differently to it which will be no use to us.
Comparative Analysis: research that compares/contrasts behaviours/ media products.
-A benefit of this is that you can use it to steal peoples ideas and could use it to identify the development of sub genres
Competitor Analysis: close analysis and rating of a range of competitor's products.-A benefit of this is gives a fuller veiw of the market, what your up against, and what your better then or different from.
-A drawback of this is that if you analyse someone elses product and its poor you will gain no help from it.